May We Suggest?

Is this it, how about this, search results.

Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Celebrity Cruises vs MSC Cruises

Sunday, June 30th

2024 Cruise Line Reviews

Celebrity Cruises Review

  • Celebrity Cruises
  • Best all-around cruise line: widest variety of destinations, ship sizes, and adventure levels
  • 13 ships in the main fleet + 3 smaller ships that visit the Galapagos Islands
  • Suitable for guests of all ages
  • Choose between Cruise-Only and All-Inclusive fares
  • Excellent track record for safety
  • Winner of multiple awards

Celebrity Cruises offers a variety of cruise experiences for all ages and to various destinations, with a fleet of over a dozen ships ranging in size from 16 to 3,260 passengers. Celebrity's dining options are renowned for their quality and variety, and the company offers both Cruise-Only and All-Inclusive fares. The cruise line has a strong commitment to safety and has never experienced a major incident, earning recognition as the Best Premium Cruise Line by Travel Weekly's Readers' Choice Awards for 14 consecutive years. Celebrity is an excellent choice for guests of all ages and interests.

MSC Cruises Review

  • MSC Cruises
  • Best for budget-friendly, Mediterranean-themed, large-ship cruising in the Caribbean, Europe, and Mediterranean
  • 23 ships in the fleet
  • Private island in the Bahamas on some itineraries

MSC Cruises is an Italian-themed, family-oriented cruise line with a fleet of 23 ships that sail to destinations worldwide. They offer a wide range of itineraries, from short Caribbean cruises to longer world cruises. Caribbean sailings are one of their specialties, with budget-friendly fares often starting at $139 per person for a three-night Bahamas cruise. However, guests should be aware of additional costs for gratuities, drinks, and dining packages, and even for basics like choosing the stateroom or dining room seating time. While the low initial fares may seem like a bargain, fees for "extras" can add up quickly, so it's worth comparing MSC to other cruise lines before booking your sailing.

More Cruise Line Reviews

Royal Caribbean Review

  • Royal Caribbean

Disney Cruise Line Review

  • Disney Cruise Line

Virgin Voyages Review

  • Virgin Voyages

Viking Cruises Review

  • Viking Cruises

Regent Seven Seas Review

  • Regent Seven Seas

Norwegian Cruise Line Review

  • Norwegian Cruise Line

Princess Cruises Review

  • Princess Cruises

Holland America Review

  • Holland America

Cunard Review

  • Carnival Cruises

The 15 Best Cruise Lines

Which cruise line is the best.

Cruising is a popular way of traveling for many people, offering a unique experience that combines the convenience of a floating hotel with the excitement of visiting multiple destinations in one trip. In an average year, over fifteen million people say "all aboard" and set sail on an amazing vacation.

There are many different cruise lines to choose from, and each one offers a different type of experience. Some are geared towards families, while others are more focused on luxury or adventure. What would you like to see and do while you're onboard? Is a casino a must-have or a rather-avoid? Would a Broadway-caliber show tip the scales for you? Do you need a wide range of activities to keep the kiddos happy while the adults live it up or relax? The onboard activities and amenities can really make or break your vacation, so be sure you know what you're getting.

The Best Cruise Lines

Cruise Line FAQ

Which cruise line is the best, what is included in the cost of a cruise, what is the minimum age to cruise, what are the dining options on a cruise ship, are cruise ships crowded, do i have to dress up, are activities included at destination ports, can i bring my own alcohol onboard.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Another factor that can influence which cruise line you choose is the itinerary. Cruise ships travel all over the world, but some cruise lines may not have destinations available where you're hoping to go. You should also consider the size of the ship: larger ships offer more amenities, but smaller ships can access ports that bigger ships can't.

Speaking of amenities, make sure you understand what you'll get as part of your fare and which extras will come with an additional cost. For example, most cruises offer drink packages for alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages, but a few have drink stations where you can get complimentary lemonade, coffee and tea. Other amenities that might be important to you are Wi-Fi, spa services, babysitting, fitness classes, and upgraded dining experiences. You can usually get a decent discount if you sign up for an amenities package before you sail, so keep an eye out for promotions in the months leading up to your sailing.

When you take a cruise, it's almost always expected that you'll tip the crew members who have attended to your needs while onboard: your cabin steward ( who probably leaves your towels folded into fun shapes every night ), your servers at your nightly meals, and the head waiter. Cruise lines have a recommended gratuity to cover all three of those staff members, usually $15-$20 per traveler, per day; the total gratuity amount may be charged automatically to your account, or you may be given envelopes to make cash payments.

While it usually isn't mandatory to pay those gratuities - you can ask to have them removed if they're applied automatically, especially if you've received poor service - it's typically considered in poor taste not to tip at the suggested levels (because crew members' salaries, much like servers at your local restaurant, are based on the expectation of tips paid by guests). And, if you receive service that goes above and beyond, adding to the recommended gratuity is always appreciated. Be aware that tips for bartenders, poolside servers, and professional services provided in the spa or elsewhere are not included in the daily suggested gratuity and may be charged automatically at the time of service.

Now that you have a good overview of the cruising experience, which cruise line should you choose? Beyond the points we already covered, here are a few additional criteria that might make it easier to pick:

  • Embarkation port. You could get a great deal on a cruise, but what will it cost you to get to the port? That could involve airfare, an overnight stay or two in a nearby hotel (so that you're less likely to be affected by travel delays), and transportation from the airport or hotel to the port. This is especially true if you're taking a cruise that departs from an international destination.
  • Perks for repeat cruisers. Like frequent flyer programs on airlines, most cruise lines offer benefits the more you sail. If you find yourself absolutely loving cruise vacations, it can be advantageous to put all of your eggs in one basket, so to speak. Rewards programs can include casino benefits, complimentary meals at the upgraded dining experiences, exclusive sail-away parties with free cocktails and tchotchkes, early-access booking on future cruises, and much more.
  • Reputation. It's a really smart idea to see what other travelers have said about their overall experience with a cruise line before booking your trip. The ads on TV may make that private island look amazing, but someone who's been there might point out that you'll pay extra to get on that waterslide. Or, previous cruisers could tell you that despite having several formal nights on the schedule, a particular cruise line has no problem with people showing up to dinner in flip-flops and swimsuit coverups. Find out if the cruise line you're considering lines up in reality with what they advertise.

Here at Top Consumer Reviews, cruising is one of our favorite ways to travel and experience new things. And with so many different cruise lines to choose from, it can be overwhelming to know where to start. But, don't worry: take a look at our in-depth analysis of today's most popular options, find the one that's the best match for your vacation ideas and your travel party, and book that trip you've been dreaming of. Bon voyage!

Compare Cruise Lines

Select any 2 Cruise Lines to compare them head to head

 alt=

Trending Cruise Line News

MarketWatch

Norwegian Cruise Line Holdings Ltd. stock outperforms competitors on ...

This was the stock's ninth consecutive day of gains.

  Fri, 28 Jun 2024

Cruise Hive

Carnival Cruise Line Responds Over Adults-Only Area Concern

What would you do if there was an infant in an adults-only area? Carnival Cruise Line has responded to one situation.

Disney Cruise Line Reveals Details About Asia-Based Cruise Ship, ...

Disney Experiences business segment will launch its first Asia-based cruise ship, the Disney Adventure in 2025.

  Wed, 26 Jun 2024

Cruise ship boarding put back two hours for cleaning

Port health officials met the ship when it docked on 25 May after a number of passengers became unwell during a two-week cruise around the Canary Islands. Cruise firm, P&O said embarkation, usually ...

Cruise Fever

Newest Cruise Ship Specialty Restaurant Finally Opens, $70 Cheaper ...

Love By Britto became the newest cruise ship specialty restaurant to officially open and the cost per person is $70 less than originally announced. Love by Britto is now officially open on Sun ...

TheStreet.com on MSN

Carnival Cruise Line shares key passport news

Some cruises from other parts of the world do require a passport. Carnival Cruise Line ( CCL) Brand Ambassador John Heald recently addressed some passport misinformation he has seen disseminated in ...

  Thu, 27 Jun 2024

Newsweek on MSN

World's Largest Cruise Ship Catches Fire

The world's largest cruise ship caught fire while docked in Costa Maya, Mexico. Flames hit the Icon of the Seas on Tuesday afternoon, but Royal Caribbean told Cruise Law News that they were "quickly ...

New York Post on MSN

Fire breaks out on Icon of the Seas — the world’s largest cruise ...

A fire broke out in a crew area of Royal Caribbean’s Icon of the Seas ship after setting sail from Florida to Mexico.

Related Cruise Line Reviews

Since you're interested in Cruise Lines, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.

Best Cruise Vacation Sites

Cruise Vacation Sites

What's the best place to book a cruise vacation? You've finally got some time off, and you've decided you want the full-experience: sailing, relaxing, and new and exciting ...

Best Luggage Stores

Luggage Stores

Which luggage store is the best? Luggage is something that everyone will need at some point in their life, whether it be a backpack for an overnight trip or school, or a full set of luggage ...

Best Photo Book Companies

Photo Book Companies

Where is the best place to get photo books out there today? Photo books are a fantastic way to keep our special memories in a tangible, beautiful format instead of just storing pictures on ...

Best Travel Insurance Plans

Travel Insurance Plans

Who offers the best travel insurance? With daily news stories of delayed and canceled flights, lost baggage, and travelers stranded overseas in the middle of a natural disaster, it's ...

Best Travel Visa Services

Travel Visa Services

What's the easiest way to get a travel visa? Online travel visa providers have revolutionized the way individuals apply for visas when planning their international trips.

Best Vacation Rental Sites

Vacation Rental Sites

What's the best website to use for booking a vacation rental? Are you tired of the same old hotel experience when you go on vacation?

The Best Reviews of Cruise Lines

Newest Reviews

Best Dryers

Where Can You Find the Best Dryer? Modern dryers offer tons of benefits that make them essential to any household.

Best Italian Lessons

Italian Lessons

Where Can You Find the Best Italian Lessons? Learning any new language opens up a world of opportunities, and Italian, with its rich history, captivating culture, and melodious rhythm, is no exception.

Best Lamp Stores

Lamp Stores

Where is the Best Place to Buy Lamps? If you're into home design, or just want to redecorate a room, you know how important lighting is.

Best Light Bulb Stores

Light Bulb Stores

What are the best places to buy light bulbs online? Light bulbs are one of those things we take for granted.

Best Washing Machines

Washing Machines

Where Can You Find the Best Washing Machine? There are tons of benefits to a modern washer.

Best Wedding Dress Stores

Wedding Dress Stores

Where is the best place to buy a wedding dress online? One of the most important purchases you will make for your wedding day is the dress.

The Best Reviews are at Top Consumer Reviews

  • Trip Itinerary Generator
  • Vacation Budget Calculator
  • Cruise Budget Calculator
  • Road Trip Budget Calculator
  • BOOK a CRUISE
  • BOOK an EXPERIENCE
  • BOOK a FLIGHT
  • BOOK a HOTEL
  • BUY TRAVEL INSURANCE
  • FAQs about virtual assistance and travel planning
  • FAQs about Viator
  • FAQs about Cruises
  • FAQs about Travel Insurance
  • Cruises reviews
  • Viator Experiences reviews
  • Hotel reviews
  • Travel Tips
  • Itineraries

You are currently viewing CELEBRITY vs MSC CRUISES review : Are they High End Cruise Lines?

CELEBRITY vs MSC CRUISES review : Are they High End Cruise Lines?

  • Post author: WorldTraveller
  • Post published: 20 December 2023
  • Post category: Cruises reviews

CruiseDirect

Get ready for the adventure of a lifetime as you explore the ultimate comparison between CELEBRITY vs MSC CRUISES. These prestigious cruise lines offer an array of luxurious amenities and unparalleled service to ensure your experience is nothing short of unforgettable. From Michelin-starred restaurants and world-class entertainment on CELEBRITY to a fusion of cultures and endless relaxation options on MSC CRUISES, there’s something for every traveler. Embark on breathtaking journeys to iconic ports and immerse yourself in awe-inspiring moments and unforgettable memories. Whether you crave refinement or cultural immersion, both CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES have got you covered. So, pack your bags and get ready to set sail on a cruise vacation like no other.

Table of Contents

Why Consider CELEBRITY vs MSC CRUISES review?

Looking for an adventure of a lifetime? Look no further than the ultimate comparison between CELEBRITY vs MSC CRUISES , two of the most prestigious cruise lines in the industry. These cruise lines offer luxurious amenities, unparalleled service, and unforgettable experiences. So why should you consider these products?

Both CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES have received rave reviews from travelers all over the world. With a plethora of scientific research and evidence supporting their effectiveness, these cruise lines have established their reputation as the go-to options for a remarkable vacation at sea. Furthermore, they have obtained various certifications and endorsements, cementing their credibility and quality in the cruise industry.

Customer testimonials also speak volumes about these cruise lines. People from all walks of life have hailed their experiences with CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES as unforgettable and life-changing. From the amazing food to the world-class entertainment, passengers have been left in awe of the exceptional service and attention to detail.

Get your own CELEBRITY vs MSC CRUISES today.

Features and Benefits of CELEBRITY vs MSC CRUISES

Culinary delights.

CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES take fine dining to a whole new level. With world-class dining options available on board, curated by Michelin-starred chefs, your taste buds are in for a treat. From exquisite seafood to delectable desserts, these cruise lines provide a journey of flavors that will leave you craving for more.

Spectacular Entertainment

When the sun sets, the entertainment begins on both CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES. Whether you prefer Broadway-style shows that will transport you to another world or live music performances that ignite your senses, you’ll never have a dull moment on board. Every evening becomes a celebration of talent and artistic brilliance.

Fusion of Cultures

MSC CRUISES specializes in cultural immersion. Their ships are like floating cities, bringing together the best of the Mediterranean, Caribbean, and beyond. Experience a fusion of cultures through authentic cuisine in elegant restaurants, prepared by skilled chefs who will leave you astounded by their culinary expertise. It’s a chance to embark on a journey of flavors from different parts of the world.

Relaxation and Wellness

Both CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES understand the need for relaxation and wellness during your vacation. Whether it’s unwinding by the poolside, enjoying a rejuvenating spa treatment, or taking part in wellness activities, these cruise lines offer endless options to ensure you return home feeling refreshed and rejuvenated.

These are just a few of the many features and benefits that CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES offer. Each cruise line has its unique specialties that make them stand out, ensuring a memorable and exceptional vacation experience.

CELEBRITY vs MSC CRUISES Quality

The quality of CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES is unparalleled in the cruise industry. Both cruise lines have invested heavily in providing a luxurious and comfortable experience for their passengers. From the moment you step onboard, you are greeted with impeccable service and attention to detail.

The ships themselves are a testament to their commitment to excellence. They are equipped with state-of-the-art facilities, ensuring a smooth and enjoyable journey for all passengers. The cabins are spacious and elegantly designed, providing a cozy haven for relaxation after a day of exploring.

It’s important to note that the dedication to quality extends beyond the physical aspects of the cruise. The staff members on both CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES are well-trained professionals who go above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction. Their warm smiles and willingness to assist create a welcoming atmosphere that enhances the overall cruise experience.

What It’s Used For

Exploring iconic ports.

Both CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES offer itineraries that allow you to explore the world’s most iconic ports. Whether you’re dreaming of strolling through the picturesque streets of Santorini or immersing yourself in the vibrant colors of the Caribbean, these cruise lines provide the perfect platform for unforgettable adventures.

If you’re traveling with children, both CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES have got you covered. These cruise lines offer kids’ clubs and dedicated teen zones, ensuring that young travelers have a blast while on board. From exciting activities to fun-filled games, there’s never a dull moment for the little ones.

Shopping Extravaganza

Who doesn’t love a little bit of retail therapy? Onboard CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES, you can indulge in a shopping extravaganza. The onboard shopping boutiques offer a wide range of duty-free products and designer brands, allowing you to splurge on souvenirs for yourself or loved ones back home.

Who Needs This

CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES cater to a wide range of travelers. Whether you’re a couple looking for a romantic getaway, a family wanting to create lasting memories, or a solo traveler seeking adventure, these cruise lines have something for everyone. Age is no barrier, as both CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES offer activities and amenities that cater to all age groups and interests.

Pros and Cons of CELEBRITY vs MSC CRUISES

  • Luxurious amenities and unparalleled service
  • World-class dining options curated by Michelin-starred chefs
  • Spectacular entertainment, including Broadway-style shows
  • Fusion of cultures and international cuisine
  • Endless options for relaxation and wellness
  • State-of-the-art facilities and spacious cabins
  • Dedicated staff members committed to customer satisfaction
  • May be expensive for some travelers
  • Itineraries may not suit everyone’s preferences

FAQ’s

Q: Are gratuities included in the cruise fare? A: CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES have different policies regarding gratuities. It is best to check with the cruise line directly for their specific guidelines.

Q: Can I bring my own alcohol on board? A: Both CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES have their own alcohol policies. It is recommended to review their guidelines before boarding the ship.

Q: Is Wi-Fi available onboard? A: Yes, both cruise lines offer Wi-Fi connectivity, although it may come at an additional cost.

What Customers Are Saying

Customers who have experienced CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES have had nothing but positive feedback. They rave about the exceptional service, delicious food, and unforgettable experiences. Many have remarked on the attention to detail and the luxurious amenities that make these cruise lines stand out from the rest.

Overall Value

When it comes to value, both CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES offer an experience like no other. The memories and moments created during your time on board are priceless. While the initial cost may seem high, the value in terms of quality, service, and unforgettable experiences far exceeds the price tag.

Tips and Tricks For Best Results

  • Plan ahead and book your desired activities and dining options in advance to secure your preferred times and dates.
  • Pack light, as cabins on cruise ships are typically compact. Opt for versatile clothing options that can be easily mixed and matched.
  • Take advantage of the onboard activities, entertainment, and amenities. There’s something for everyone, so make the most of your time on board.

Final Thoughts

Celebrity vs msc cruises summary.

In summary, CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES are two of the most prestigious cruise lines in the industry, offering luxurious amenities, unparalleled service, and unforgettable experiences. From world-class dining options to spectacular entertainment, there is something for everyone on these cruise lines. The quality, attention to detail, and dedication to customer satisfaction make CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES stand out in the industry.

Final Recommendation

So, pack your bags and get ready for a cruise vacation like no other! Whether you choose CELEBRITY for its refined and extravagant experience or MSC CRUISES for its diverse and culturally immersive atmosphere, rest assured that both cruise lines will exceed your expectations. Embark on the adventure of a lifetime with CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES and create memories that will last a lifetime.

Click to view the CELEBRITY vs MSC CRUISES .

WorldTraveller

You might also like.

Read more about the article COSTA vs OCEANIA CRUISES review

COSTA vs OCEANIA CRUISES review

Read more about the article CARNIVAL vs CUNARD CRUISES Review

CARNIVAL vs CUNARD CRUISES Review

Read more about the article AZAMARA vs REGENT CRUISES review

AZAMARA vs REGENT CRUISES review

Cruise Spotlight

Helping you find cruise ships you'll love

MSC Seashore vs Celebrity Beyond

MSC Seashore cruise ship

The MSC Seashore was built in 2021. The MSC Seaside has a New York City-inspired theme complete with a 10-foot-fall replica of the Statue of Liberty at the heart of the casino and shopping area called Times Square. It's 1 year older than the Beyond , which was built in 2022. The Celebrity Beyond is a step up from its siblings, with an additional deck and more outdoor space. It still features the "Magic Carpet," a moving platform that makes using water tenders a breeze while in port, or adds outdoor dining space while at sea. This Edge-class of ship is known to feel quite different than the rest of the Celebrity fleet as it's less geared towards traditional cruise passengers.

Comparison Overview

Number of passengers, food and restaurants.

  • Bars and Drinks

Pools and Hot Tubs

Ship features and activities, cruise costs, onboard costs.

The Seashore is considered a large size ship. Coming in at 1,060 feet long and 135 feet wide, it's roughly the length of 2.9 football fields, as wide as 2.5 tractor-trailers and the same height as a 15-story building. Compared to the Celebrity Beyond, the Seashore is 20% larger in terms of overall tons.

MSC Seashore holds 73% more passengers than the Beyond based on double occupancy (two people per room). When you look at the "Space Ratio," or the total tonnage of a ship compared to the number of passengers, the Seashore has less space per person compared to the Beyond.

HOLA! Tacos & Cantina on the MSC Seashore

Food is a big part of any cruise, and the ship you choose can make a huge difference in your food experience.

The Seashore has 16 different dining options like HOLA! Tacos & Cantina , Butcher's Cut , and Kaito Sushi Bar . Of those options, 7 are complementary, or included with your cruise fare. The other 9 options have an additional fee.

The Beyond has 3 more dining venues. Some of its popular venues are Le Grand Bistro , Cosmopolitan Restaurant , and Magic Carpet . 8 of these restaurants are complementary and the other 11 have an additional fee.

If you like having a variety of places to eat, the Beyond might be a better choice. It has 19% more dining options than the Seashore.

Both ships have a similar number of paid versus included dining options.

In terms of drinks and cocktails, you have a variety of choices. Both ships serve the Coca-cola family of products. That means Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite and Barqs Root Beer, although the selection can vary by ship.

There are also plenty of bars available on these ships. Alcohol is not included in the base price of this cruise ship. To see if you would save money with a drink package, try our Drink Package Calculator.

Long Island Pool on MSC Seashore

Nothing beats relaxing by a pool with a nice drink in hand as you feel the fresh sea breeze pass by you. The problem is that with thousands of people on a ship, there's not always room. If you want to spend all day for 7 days in a pool, a cruise isn't for you. You would have a much better bet choosing a resort with a huge pool complex. That being said, a quick dip in the pool can be nice on a hot day.

The MSC Seashore has a total of 5 pools and 15 hot tubs. Tired of loud kids and splashing? 1 of the pools are adults only. 2 of the pools and 3 of the hot tubs are exclusive access, which means there's either an extra charge to access them or you need to book a certain class of cabin to have access to them.

The Celebrity Beyond has the same number of pools as the Seashore and fewer hot tubs. There are fewer exclusive pools and hot tubs on the Beyond. If you like ships without extra charges or exclusive areas, this might be a better choice since everyone will have access to these areas.

Both ships have lots of activities to keep you busy throughout your cruise. Below you'll see a list of some of the major features on these ships. You might up paying more while on board the Seashore. Only 54% of the activities below are included in your cruise fare. On the Beyond, 67% of the activities are included at no additional cost.

MSC is considered a mainstream cruise line. Mainstream cruise lines cater to a variety of guests, hoping to provide something for everyone. These typically cost about $100 - $350 per person per day.

Celebrity, on the other hand, is a premium cruise line. Premium cruise lines typically offer upscale food, accommodations, and service. These typically cost about $150 - $400 per person per day.

Cruise pricing is dynamic and varies for each specific sailing based on factors such as departure point, ports of call, and time of year. To get a good idea of how the pricing compares, visit the cruise line's website to price out the separate cruises or consult a travel professional.

Another way to gauge the cost of a cruise is to consider how much you'll spend on board. Even though a lot is included in the base cruise fare, you may still spend money on things like spa treatments, specialty dining, drinks, and excursions. In addition, guests can also have to pay for things like gratuities and tips.

Typically guests can expect to spend about 25 - 40% of the cost of the cruise on onboard expenses. In other words, if the cruise fare is $1,000 per person, you might spend between $250 and $400 on extra expenses.

The table below will help you compare onboard prices to see if you might spend more on a specific ship.

Celebrity Cruise Lines offers an "All Included" program. Guests who book a cruise using this promotion will have gratuities and alcohol included. Some sailings are available without this program so pay attention when booking. Typically prices are lower if they don't include "Always Included." The wifi and alcohol package are the base levels and can be upgraded for an additional cost.

Want to Stay Up-To-Date on All Things Cruising?

Follow us on Facebook , Instagram , Threads , or subscribe to our monthly newsletter .

Articles Related the These Ships

msc cruise vs celebrity

How Celebrity Beyond is Different from Edge and Apex

Cruise ships to look forward to in 2022.

Which cruise brand is best for you? A guide to the most popular lines

Gene Sloan

Thinking about booking your first cruise? The sheer range of choices can be daunting. There are more than two dozen lines marketing to North Americans — no two alike.

The list of brands includes everything from giant companies such as Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line, which are household names, to lesser-known small operators such as Windstar Cruises.

Some of the brands — Royal Caribbean, MSC Cruises and Norwegian Cruise Line, in particular — operate massive vessels that are like giant floating resorts with deck-top water parks and other over-the-top amusements . Others specialize in intimate, boutique hotel-style ships.

For more cruise guides, news and tips, sign up for TPG's cruise newsletter.

Some lines, such as Carnival, are aimed at a budget crowd. Others operate vessels that are as luxurious as any upscale resort found on land. A few small luxury players such as Regent Seven Seas Cruises have ships with lavish suites that'll cost you as much as $11,000 a day .

Where should you start your search for the perfect cruise for you? Below, you'll find our quick guide to some of the most popular cruise brands. As you'll see, it's not meant to be an in-depth review of the lines. It's just a short overview — enough to give you a sense of which particular cruise operator might best appeal to you.

Once you've narrowed down the choices to a few brands that you think best fit your style, do a deeper dive into them and their specific ships, their itineraries and home ports and their comparable costs (either on your own or with the help of a cruise-savvy travel agent ). Note that TPG has many guides to individual lines, which you can find by clicking on our cruise line hub pages linked in each segment below.

Related: TPG's ultimate guide to picking a cruise line

With just four ships, each holding fewer than 700 passengers, Azamara is one of the smallest players in the cruise business. But it has a loyal following of travelers who appreciate the upscale ambience of its vessels, the inclusive amenities it offers (including gratuities and alcoholic drinks) and its destination focus.

The line prides itself on offering longer stays in ports, including multi-day visits. Its ships have an intimate, boutique-hotel feel. Pricing is higher than at the big, mass-market lines but not quite as high as you'll find at luxury lines.

Related: 5 things to love about Azamara's newest ship

Carnival Cruise Line

msc cruise vs celebrity

The self-described "fun ship" line is the king of short, affordable, fun-focused cruises from U.S. ports to the Caribbean, the Bahamas, Mexico and beyond.

The choice of roughly one in five cruisers, Carnival Cruise Line' s ships are notoriously lively, flashy and packed with fun features such as water parks with multiple waterslides. Just don't expect anything too fancy .

Related: The ultimate guide to Carnival Cruise Line

Celebrity Cruises

msc cruise vs celebrity

Designed to be a cut above mainstream options such as Carnival while remaining relatively affordable, this Miami-based "premium" line is known for some of the most stylish big ships at sea.

Expect high-end design, cutting-edge art and trendy restaurants. In short, Celebrity aims for sophisticates, not the party crowd (although it's not a luxury product).

Celebrity's four newest ships, Celebrity Edge , Celebrity Apex , Celebrity Beyond and Celebrity Ascent, feature "infinite veranda" cabins that are open to the sea in a way we haven't seen with other ocean ships. They boast a glass wall that opens from the top to create a balcony-like effect.

Crystal Cruises

msc cruise vs celebrity

This much-beloved luxury line recently restarted operations under new owners after shutting down for 18 months. For years, it was considered the ultimate luxury cruise operator, and our take after sailing on Crystal Serenity after its relaunch is that the line is even better than before. Initially, Crystal has returned to operations with just two ships. But it recently announced plans to expand rapidly with four more ships over the next six years.

A storied line with roots that go back to the 1800s, this three-ship brand is perhaps best known for its 2,695-passenger flagship, Queen Mary 2. The ship lives up to its billing as a true ocean liner with semiregular, transatlantic service between Southampton, England, and New York.

Cunard fans love the line's relatively formal vibe (including nightly dress codes) and other nods to ocean liner tradition, including evenings with ballroom dancing. A fourth Cunard ship called Queen Anne is set to debut in 2024.

Related: Why I was wrong about transatlantic cruises

Disney Cruise Line

msc cruise vs celebrity

Meet-and-greets with Disney characters, Disney-themed shows and the most extensive kiddie fun zones on the high seas are just a few of the family-friendly allures of a Disney cruise . If you're a Disney fan, nothing quite compares.

If Disney isn't your thing, well, this probably isn't the line for you. The biggest downside of the brand? As with Disney's parks on land, it doesn't come cheap.

Related: A first-look photo tour of Disney's newest ship, Disney Wish

Holland America

Tradition long has been a touchstone for this storied line, which dates to 1873 and is known for carefully crafted, globe-circling itineraries on midsize ships.

However, Holland America has been shaking things up in recent years with lively new venues such as B.B. King's Blues Club. Couples and retirees are the market for this line. Families with kids might want to look elsewhere.

MSC Cruises

msc cruise vs celebrity

A giant of cruising in Europe, Switzerland-based MSC Cruises is making a big play for North Americans with newer, bigger ships sailing year-round from Florida to the Caribbean and Bahamas. It also offers sailings from New York City.

Like Royal Caribbean and Norwegian, MSC Cruises operates big, resort-like vessels that appeal to a broad audience. Among the highlight of its cruises in North America are stops at its new private island in the Bahamas, the Ocean Cay MSC Marine Reserve .

Norwegian Cruise Line

msc cruise vs celebrity

Multistory waterslides, ropes courses and even go-kart race tracks are among the gee-whiz attractions atop Norwegian Cruise Line 's giant, resort-like ships. The vessels also are packed with eateries, bars, casinos and showrooms.

The brand is known for its entertainment, including big Broadway shows such as "Beetlejuice." If you're looking for a Las Vegas-style resort at sea, this is your line.

Oceania Cruises

Oceania has carved out a niche with relatively small, upscale ships that offer a significant upgrade from mass-market vessels but aren't quite as fancy (or pricey) as luxury offerings.

Its seven ships feature a relaxed, country club-like ambience and inspired dining that appeal to a mostly older crowd.

Itinerary-wise, Oceania is known for destination-intensive voyages that typically are 10 nights or more in length, with some globe-circling trips as long as 180 days.

Related: Take a look at Vista, Oceania's stunning new ship

This France-based line is a specialist in expedition cruising , a type of cruising that involves traveling to remote, hard-to-reach places on small, hardy vessels that carry their own landing craft.

Operating a fast-growing fleet of tough but upscale expedition ships (none carrying more than 264 passengers), Ponant is known for voyages to places like Antarctica and the Arctic.

If you're looking for waterslides and laser tag, this is not the cruise line for you.

Related: This epic Ponant trip will take you to the North Pole

Princess Cruises

msc cruise vs celebrity

Popular with middle-aged couples, retirees and multigenerational families, the "Love Boat" line's ships aren't as flashy (or big, for the most part) as those of Royal Caribbean and Norwegian, and that's just the way its customers like it.

Princess Cruises ' customers also like its wide range of itineraries, including voyages in Asia and Australia, as well as closer-to-home places like the Caribbean. It's long been one of the dominant lines in the Alaska cruise market.

Related: The ultimate guide to Princess Cruises

Regent Seven Seas Cruises

This Miami-based luxury line operates some of the most opulent vessels at sea, including three recently unveiled Explorer-class ships billed as the most expensive luxury vessels ever built on a cost-per-berth basis.

Regent Seven Seas Cruises is particularly known for some of the most over-the-top suites at sea (including some bigger than the average American home ), some of the most inclusive fares in the cruise business and high levels of service. The only catch: You'll pay a pretty penny for it. Rooms on Regent ships start at around $1,000 per person per day and can cost as much as $5,500 per person per day.

Royal Caribbean

msc cruise vs celebrity

For megaresort fans, there's nothing quite like a Royal Caribbean vessel.

The line's biggest ships are more than 20% bigger than almost any others afloat (only MSC Cruises has ships that come close in size) and feature every type of amusement imaginable, from rock climbing walls and surfing pools to Broadway shows and ice skating rinks.

Families, in particular, will love this line, due to all the family-friendly activities and venues on its vessels. Royal Caribbean ships sail everywhere in the world, but the line's heaviest presence is in the Caribbean and Europe.

Related: The ultimate guide to Royal Caribbean

Another leader in luxury cruising, this seven-ship brand offers all-suite vessels, top-notch service and elegant cuisine.

As with other luxury lines, Seabourn offers a wide range of itineraries around the globe. It also recently jumped into more adventurous, expedition-style cruising with two new 264-passenger vessels designed to operate in polar regions such as Antarctica and the Arctic.

Silversea Cruises

msc cruise vs celebrity

Exquisite service, refined dining and well-appointed accommodations are hallmarks of this Monaco-based luxury line with 12 vessels. Silversea Cruises is also known for its industry-leading array of off-the-beaten-path itineraries.

Its growing fleet of small expedition ships will take you everywhere from the Arctic to Papua New Guinea in style.

The Ritz-Carlton Yacht Collection

msc cruise vs celebrity

Fans of upscale hotel chain Ritz-Carlton will feel at home on one of this line's yacht-like vessels. Or, at least, that's the idea.

The cruising arm of Ritz-Carlton has been in operation for just a bit over a year, and the jury still is out on where it ranks in the pantheon of luxury cruise brands. The line notably struggled to get off the ground after years of construction delays for its first and only ship.

Dubbed Evrima, the line's only operating ship is a 298-passenger vessel designed to appeal to Ritz-Carlton regulars with an elegant, residential look. A second, bigger ship called Ilma that's already open for bookings debuts later this year.

Related: The ultimate guide to the Ritz-Carlton Yacht Collection

msc cruise vs celebrity

This fast-growing line has dominated the world of river cruising for North Americans for years, and in the last few years, it's become a significant player in upscale ocean cruising as well. Viking 's 80 river ships operate on just about every major river in the world, and its 10 ocean ships (up from just one in 2015) can be found in a growing number of destinations, too.

Viking is known for impeccably designed vessels with modern Scandinavian interiors and offering unusual, port-intensive itineraries. They also operate with a mostly all-inclusive format, as Viking long has subscribed to a "no nickel-and-diming" philosophy. Just don't bother booking the family. Kids under 18 aren't allowed on Viking.

Related: The ultimate guide to Viking cruises

Virgin Voyages

msc cruise vs celebrity

This relatively new cruise line, backed by Richard Branson's Virgin Group, is reinventing mainstream cruising with a hipper, more inclusive, younger vibe (though not too young; its ships are adults-only). Think tattoo shops, karoake booths and no upcharges for tips or eateries.

Virgin Voyages ' first three ships ( Scarlet Lady , Valiant Lady and Resilient Lady ) have suites by acclaimed designer Tom Dixon. Destinations include the Dominican Republic, Mexico and a private beach club in the Bahamas, as well as parts of Europe and Australia.

Related: I've been on more than 150 cruise ships; here's why I loved my first Virgin sailing

Windstar Cruises

If the idea of sailing on a big ship makes you cringe, small-ship specialist Windstar could be the answer.

Its six vessels carry just 148 to 342 passengers — fewer than fit on a single big-ship lifeboat — and are wonderfully intimate.

Romantic types will love Windstar's three vessels with sails — a relative rarity. Foodies can choose one of the James Beard-themed cruises, which include market tours and cooking demonstrations with a James Beard Award-winning chef.

More guides that will help you plan a cruise:

  • The 5 most desirable cabin locations on any cruise ship
  • The 8 worst cabin locations on any cruise ship
  • 21 tips and tricks that will make your cruise go smoothly
  • 15 ways cruisers waste money
  • 15 best cruises for people who never want to grow up
  • What to pack for your first cruise
  • Guide to picking a cruise line
  • MSC Cruises

MSC vs Celebrity?

By artistcleveland , January 11, 2011 in MSC Cruises

Recommended Posts

50+ Club

artistcleveland

I've done 3 Celeb cruises, only recently heard of MSC.

Anyone able to compare the 2? We prefer Europe/mediterranean, outside/veranda cabins, and No Smoking (turned off by Holland Am).

Link to comment

Share on other sites.

500+ Club

cruisingcanadian

I've done 3 Celeb cruises, only recently heard of MSC. Anyone able to compare the 2? We prefer Europe/mediterranean, outside/veranda cabins, and No Smoking (turned off by Holland Am).

I consider MSC the smokiest cruise line of all I had experienced (RCL,NCL, Celebrity and Princess). Even though there are some rules regarding where is smoking allowed they are generally not enforced-and Europeans sailing on MSC ships smoke a lot!:eek:

Go here, count the one stars for MSC:

http://www.cruisecritic.com/memberreviews/msc-cruises/cl/

Now go here, count the stars for Celebrity:

http://www.cruisecritic.com/memberreviews/celebrity-cruises/cl/

Now go here, see what the Italians think:

http://www.microsofttranslator.com/bv.aspx?from=&to=en&a=http%3A%2F%2Fforum.crocieristi.it%2Fshowthread.php%2F3066-Miglior-compagnia-crocieristica%3Fs%3D72fa70dad7ce55bfd983e30bab9e343f

There is no comparison, it is a low class, low budget smokey cruise line.

No further questions...

Absolutely loved every aspect of our cruise on Celebrity Mercury.

In comparison, MSC Poesia was like spending 18 days in a giant floating ashtray.

Capricruiser

Capricruiser

On our Poesia cruise in June 2010 we found the ship to be almost smoke free. Aside from the authorized smoking areas which did not affect us at all, the remaining areas were blissfully smoke-free. There is absolutely no smoking in the restaurants, theatre, spa, corridors, etc. One half of most bars and the outside decks was reserved for smokers but the smell did not penetrate the smoke-free areas. The casino of course was a smokers haven.

It smell pretty bad on the Musica casino (east med.).

@ artistcleveland, just do a search for "smoking" on these MSC forums and you'll get some idea of the reality of the situation. Smoking is a frequently raised topic here as well as in MSC reviews ... and there's a reason for that fact.

lddam

My wife and I have cruised on Celebrity's Constellation (2Xs), Millennium, Solstice, and Mercury; and on MSC twice, most recently on Poesia to New England and Canada. Both lines do Europe and both have outside/veranda cabins, so those aspects are a wash. Although, you will have a greater variety of veranda/suite cabins from which to choose than on MSC. The biggest difference between the two is their respective smoking policies, and if you are turned off by smoking pax and/or the stale smell of lingering cigarette smoke, then MSC is definitely not the line for you.

On Poesia, for example, the venues for much of the entertainment and activities takes place in the bars. As an earlier poster has said, smoking is permitted in one-half of most bars on MSC. The logic of how this benefits the comfort of non-smokers is beyond me because no effort is made to contain the smoke/odor to the smoking side of the room. To expect the smoke and smell to not permeate the entire room is ridiculous and makes as much sense as saying that it's possible for a woman to only get half pregnant.

Our bottom line opinion is this: If you are offended by tobacco smoke/odor, then MSC is not the line for you.

bennob66

Based on my family who has recently been on the Splendida, MSC do not seem to restrict how much duty free cigarettes and alcohol is bought onto the ship. This in turn results in a lot of drunk europeans who smoke excessively on the ship. Needless to say my family had a balcony and mainly spent their time there or in the port. It was a week long cruise and few people spoke english on the cruise anyway. If you are happy to use MSC as a floating hotel and not use the public areas much then this is fine otherwise choose elsewhere!!

Thanks for all the replies; that settles it for me!

Cool Cruiser

THE KEY - You get what you pay for! If you pay for coffe do not demand nor expect champagne.

If you try MSC do not expect it to be Celeb cruises, and you can enjoy.

It can be stiff and a bit borring on Celeb cruises as manny guest go to bed early. It can be more dance and more fun and more relaxed on MSC and Costa.

We have tried several cruiselines and love them all, for different reason.

You can find people complain for the most stupid things on this board. When I read what some people write, have thy been on the same ship, or have the lost all monny on black Jack.... why do the leave home, some should stay at home, the are not "fit" for travel among other people.

I can´t understand how it can be so hard for some people to find something nice to eat with al the alternative on menue and bare in

mind the option to request for next day.

This people must have the same problem with resturants on shore.

An open mind:cool:, a smile:), and I hope you will enjoy;), but If you

pay for coffe do not demand nor expect champagne.

Happy Cruise:)

Regarding smoking, I just read through some threads on the smoking subject on the RCCL and Celebrity forums and found that evidently the smoking problem on those lines is very similar to MSC - all have strong smoking policies and all have problems with enforcement. I do however like Celebrity's policy of a $250 fine for passengers who chose to ignore the rules.

... I just read through some threads on the smoking subject on the RCCL and Celebrity forums and found that evidently the smoking problem on those lines is very similar to MSC ...
Having cruised on both MSC and Celebrity, my experience is that they're at opposite ends of the spectrum when it comes to smoking. On Celebrity we didn't encounter any sort of "smoking problem". We never noticed smokers and were never affected or restricted by smokers. In contrast, apart from the theatre and dining areas, there was barely anywhere on Poesia where we could go without being affected by smokers. This included most of the lounges and bars ... especially the large Pigalle lounge where many mainstream activities are held ... but which "welcomes smokers".

Thanks Andrew, it is appreciated that you have also actually sailed both lines and are qualified to answer the question, rather than just postings suppositions and second hand reports.

What lines have you cruised on, Zambini?

MTL=CRUISEFAMILY

MTL=CRUISEFAMILY

I had issues with smoking too, the Lirica was much more controlled, the Poesia, not so much.

The large Zebra lounge, where most of the evening activities were held luckily did not allow for smoking, but to get to it you had to pass a few smoking lounges.

AndrewK, how is the situation in Australia, Re:Flood levels? I assume you are not in the vicinity of these?

Service style between X and MSC is very similar (friendly but less persistently gregarious than some lines). Food is better on X (IMHO) and less consistent on MSC.

Smoking - X is more stringently smoke free (or 'anti' smoking) than other North American big ship lines. MSC comes from the other end of the spectrum (Europe is about a decade behind North America in public smoking attitudes and policies [but catching up fast]) so MSC is NOT the choice if you're smoke sensitive.

On my MSC cruise in the Med the port side of the pool deck and one of the bigger aft lounges was open to smoking - it was apparent. Staff enforced smoking prohibitions elsewhere. For me the smoke issue wasn't terrible, especially if you recollected that 20 years ago smoking was virtually everywhere (I remember being on an Olympic airlines 707 at JFK in '68 delayed, no a/c, you couldn't see across the cabin - cough cough; think of that when folks pine for cruising like in the 'good old days'!).

MSC is an OK line, but its not the best choice for the smoke sensitive.

Which ones haven't I? LOL!

When I first started cruising, I thought I would try them all( within my budget of course) and didn't really care for a loyalty program.

Now, I see others with lots of perks such as Diamond plus for cruising with RCCL and tend to get jealous, but then I remember I don't like RCCL that much and remember how much fun I like trying new lines so ~

prolly never:

Azamara & Hal (two favorites)

... Off topic: AndrewK, how is the situation in Australia, Re:Flood levels? I assume you are not in the vicinity of these?

Thank you for thinking about us.

I'm on the mid-north coast of New South Wales and we're not affected here. We have many cruising friends as well as family in Queensland but thankfully everyone is fine.

The situation is still very bad in many parts of Queensland and also in northern New South Wales. The situation is improving in the Queensland state capital Brisbane, but there will be a very lengthy and expensive cleanup required. The effects will be felt for years to come.

Some cruises depart from Brisbane (particularly P&O and Princess) but at the moment the port is completely closed to all shipping.

Our thoughts also go out to Sri Lanka and Brazil ... both are experiencing disastrous flooding with many lives lost. Kind of puts the antics on these forums into perspective doesn't it.

Thank you for thinking about us. I'm on the mid-north coast of New South Wales and we're not affected here. We have many cruising friends as well as family in Queensland but thankfully everyone is fine. The situation is still very bad in many parts of Queensland and also in northern New South Wales. The situation is improving in the Queensland state capital Brisbane, but there will be a very lengthy and expensive cleanup required. The effects will be felt for years to come. Some cruises depart from Brisbane (particularly P&O and Princess) but at the moment the port is completely closed to all shipping. Our thoughts also go out to Sri Lanka and Brazil ... both are experiencing disastrous flooding with many lives lost. Kind of puts the antics on these forums into perspective doesn't it.

Carnival is on the way, no tipping!

http://www.cruisecritic.com/news/news.cfm?ID=4311

T Kind of puts the antics on these forums into perspective doesn't it.

The evening news covers it extensively, between the flooding and Haiti disaster it kinda makes you enjoy what we have and take for granted.

Carnival is on the way, no tipping!   http://www.cruisecritic.com/news/news.cfm?ID=4311

Yes ... I read that article earlier this morning. More competition has to be good for the consumer!

Interesting to see that they've done their homework and are "adjusting" the product to suit the Australian market.

Yes ... I read that article earlier this morning. More competition has to be good for the consumer! Interesting to see that they've done their homework and are "adjusting" the product to suit the Australian market.

If I'm not mistaken, don't you Aussies pay a lot more for cruises than the rest of us and aren't you banned from purchasing thru a US website?

It will be interesting to see how the prices and bookings will be handled, if I'll book here or there, so to speak.

OP, I apologize for us hijacking your thread...

Yes ... I read that article earlier this morning. More competition has to be good for the consumer! Interesting to see that they've done their homework and are "adjusting" the product to suit the Australian market .

Maybe they read CC ;)

I'm sure they will bring you a good, competitive product; lots of value for the money in my opinion.

... If I'm not mistaken, don't you Aussies pay a lot more for cruises than the rest of us and aren't you banned from purchasing thru a US website? ...

My apologies also to the OP for the off-topic discussion.

Yes, correct on both counts. Prices are relatively higher here, but the lines which have ships positioned here have removed tipping so it balances out to some extent. It doesn't seem to have affected sales ... the cruise market is booming here.

I think the restrictions on purchasing through overseas web sites came about because local travel agents were being disadvantaged. It never affects us anyway. If we see something advertised which appeals to us we just go and ask our local T.A. about it and book through them if we decide to go.

My wife is elite on Princess ... owned by Carnival. It will be interesting to see if that transfers over to Carnival itself. Carnival will be joining P&O and Princess in running cruises out to the Pacific Islands as well as New Zealand. We really enjoy those itineraries.

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in

  • Welcome to Cruise Critic
  • ANNOUNCEMENT: Set Sail on Sun Princess®
  • Hurricane Zone 2024
  • Cruise Insurance Q&A w/ Steve Dasseos of Tripinsurancestore.com June 2024
  • New Cruisers
  • Cruise Lines “A – O”
  • Cruise Lines “P – Z”
  • River Cruising
  • Cruise Critic News & Features
  • Digital Photography & Cruise Technology
  • Special Interest Cruising
  • Cruise Discussion Topics
  • UK Cruising
  • Australia & New Zealand Cruisers
  • Canadian Cruisers
  • North American Homeports
  • Ports of Call
  • Cruise Conversations

Announcements

  • New to Cruise Critic? Join our Community!

Write Your Own Amazing Review !

WAR_icy_SUPERstar777.jpg

Click this gorgeous photo by member SUPERstar777 to share your review!

Features & News

LauraS

LauraS · Started Thursday at 08:52 PM

LauraS · Started Thursday at 07:30 PM

LauraS · Started Tuesday at 05:03 PM

LauraS · Started Tuesday at 03:34 PM

LauraS · Started Tuesday at 03:22 PM

hal5starpcbest2024.jpg

  • Existing user? Sign in OR Create an Account
  • Find Your Roll Call
  • Meet & Mingle
  • Community Help Center
  • All Activity
  • Member Photo Albums
  • Meet & Mingle Photos
  • Favorite Cruise Memories
  • Cruise Food Photos
  • Cruise Ship Photos
  • Ports of Call Photos
  • Towel Animal Photos
  • Amazing, Funny & Totally Awesome Cruise Photos
  • Write a Review
  • Live Cruise Reports
  • Member Cruise Reviews
  • Create New...

msc cruise vs celebrity

TravelReveal

TravelReveal

15 Cruise Lines Perfect for Solo Travelers

Posted: June 28, 2024 | Last updated: June 28, 2024

<p>The travel landscape is evolving, with solo <a href="https://travelreveal.com/adventure/">adventures </a>experiencing a significant boom. While cruises might not be the first thought for independent explorers, several cruise lines are now actively searching for solo travelers. We’ve curated a list of the<a href="https://travelreveal.com/adventure/15-cruise-lines-for-solo-travelers/"> top 15 cruise lines</a> catering to independent explorers, offering exceptional solo-friendly amenities and a diverse range of destinations to set sail towards.</p>

The travel landscape is evolving, with solo adventures experiencing a significant boom. While cruises might not be the first thought for independent explorers, several cruise lines are now actively searching for solo travelers. We’ve curated a list of the top 15 cruise lines catering to independent explorers, offering exceptional solo-friendly amenities and a diverse range of destinations to set sail towards.

<p>Celebrity Apex is the #1 ship for singles looking to mingle. There are several options for solo travelers to mingle, such as social events and solo excursions. There are also studio-style rooms available for singles. </p>

Celebrity Cruises

Celebrity Apex is the #1 ship for singles looking to mingle. There are several options for solo travelers to mingle, such as social events and solo excursions. There are also studio-style rooms available for singles.

<p>There are two cabin categories for solo travelers. The first is the ‘seriously suites, ‘ which are more upscale. The other is the studio cabin, which is for singles who do not prefer to spend extra money on their room but rather on the adventure. Virgin Voyages cruise ships offer adults fun activities on and off-board, like a record shop, tattoo parlor, and fine dining restaurants, which are rare on cruises. </p>

Virgin Voyages

There are two cabin categories for solo travelers. The first is the ‘seriously suites, ‘ which are more upscale. The other is the studio cabin, which is for singles who do not prefer to spend extra money on their room but rather on the adventure. Virgin Voyages cruise ships offer adults fun activities on and off-board, like a record shop, tattoo parlor, and fine dining restaurants, which are rare on cruises.

<p>Oceania offers solo cabins as the market for solo traveling continues growing tremendously. The Concierge Level Solo Veranda stateroom is available for singles looking to cruise lavishly. Oceania offers rooms catered to singles and holds mixers, communal dining tables, and interactive shore excursions to meet as many people as possible. </p>

Oceania Cruises

Oceania offers solo cabins as the market for solo traveling continues growing tremendously. The Concierge Level Solo Veranda stateroom is available for singles looking to cruise lavishly. Oceania offers rooms catered to singles and holds mixers, communal dining tables, and interactive shore excursions to meet as many people as possible.

<p>From mixers to cocktail parties, games, and excursions, Holland America Line is prepared to host those single cruisers. Another impressive feature of this cruise line is its Single Partner Program, allowing single/ solo passengers of the same sex to share a cabin (they must agree). This program will enable travelers to meet new people and purchase a cabin fit for two people for the price of one. </p>

Holland America Line

From mixers to cocktail parties, games, and excursions, Holland America Line is prepared to host those single cruisers. Another impressive feature of this cruise line is its Single Partner Program, allowing single/ solo passengers of the same sex to share a cabin (they must agree). This program will enable travelers to meet new people and purchase a cabin fit for two people for the price of one.

<p>Princess Cruise Line has established itself as a single/solo-friendly cruise with a boatload of events catered to singles. For example, the cruise line holds cocktail parties exclusively for singles, allowing these solo travelers to mingle with one another on board. Not only does this cruise line have cocktail parties, but it also offers several activities like yoga, tennis, and cooking classes catered to single travelers. </p>

Princess Cruises

Princess Cruise Line has established itself as a single/solo-friendly cruise with a boatload of events catered to singles. For example, the cruise line holds cocktail parties exclusively for singles, allowing these solo travelers to mingle with one another on board. Not only does this cruise line have cocktail parties, but it also offers several activities like yoga, tennis, and cooking classes catered to single travelers.

<p>Norwegian Cruise Line was one of the first major cruise lines to promote the single-cruising trend. Now, on six of their cruise ships, singles can reserve a studio-style stateroom perfect for just one. In addition to the studios, single cruisers have access to their exclusive studio lounge, allowing all singles to interact and meet one another in a secluded space. </p>

Norwegian Cruise Line

Norwegian Cruise Line was one of the first major cruise lines to promote the single-cruising trend. Now, on six of their cruise ships, singles can reserve a studio-style stateroom perfect for just one. In addition to the studios, single cruisers have access to their exclusive studio lounge, allowing all singles to interact and meet one another in a secluded space.

<p>Cunard Cruise Lines offers exceptional singles-only cruises, but you should only choose this line if you want to sail across numerous oceans. With the abundance of sea days vs port days, singles and solo travelers will have enough time to meet one another on these ships. Also, the convivial onboard atmosphere practically sets up solo travelers to interact with each other.</p>

Cunard Line

Cunard Cruise Lines offers exceptional singles-only cruises, but you should only choose this line if you want to sail across numerous oceans. With the abundance of sea days vs port days, singles and solo travelers will have enough time to meet one another on these ships. Also, the convivial onboard atmosphere practically sets up solo travelers to interact with each other.

<p>Royal Caribbean has somewhat copied what Norwegian has offered to solo travelers. In RC’s new and old cruise ships, solo cabins are available for those traveling alone. Now, Norweigan’s solo cabins provide no view of any sort, but Royal Caribbean has to one-up them in terms of this. All the studio cabins offer either an ocean view with a balcony or a virtual balcony (basically looks like a veranda, but it portrays the real-time view of outside). Royal Caribbean allows solo travelers to meet up with others by hosting meet-ups dedicated to those traveling solo, so there will be a chance to find others in the same boat as you!</p>

Royal Caribbean International

Royal Caribbean has somewhat copied what Norwegian has offered to solo travelers. In RC’s new and old cruise ships, solo cabins are available for those traveling alone. Now, Norweigan’s solo cabins provide no view of any sort, but Royal Caribbean has to one-up them in terms of this. All the studio cabins offer either an ocean view with a balcony or a virtual balcony (basically looks like a veranda, but it portrays the real-time view of outside). Royal Caribbean allows solo travelers to meet up with others by hosting meet-ups dedicated to those traveling solo, so there will be a chance to find others in the same boat as you!

<p>Renowned for unparalleled luxury, Seabourn caters to solo travelers seeking an indulgent adventure. Their intimate ships create a cozy atmosphere, ideal for unwinding and enjoying personalized service. Whether you’re soaking up the sun on a private balcony or indulging in world-class cuisine, Seabourn ensures an unforgettable solo travel experience. </p>

Seabourn Cruises

Renowned for unparalleled luxury, Seabourn caters to solo travelers seeking an indulgent adventure. Their intimate ships create a cozy atmosphere, ideal for unwinding and enjoying personalized service. Whether you’re soaking up the sun on a private balcony or indulging in world-class cuisine, Seabourn ensures an unforgettable solo travel experience.

<p>MSC has multiple ships catering to single travelers. Over five ships have studio interior and exterior staterooms dedicated to solo travelers. Not only does this cruise line cater to solo travelers with staterooms, but it also hosts a few different events to have other solo travelers mingle. MSC’s complimentary cocktail parties invite singles to mix and mingle in a more secluded environment. Also, the amount of onboard entertainment and activities allows countless meeting opportunities for solo travelers. </p>

MSC Cruises

MSC has multiple ships catering to single travelers. Over five ships have studio interior and exterior staterooms dedicated to solo travelers. Not only does this cruise line cater to solo travelers with staterooms, but it also hosts a few different events to have other solo travelers mingle. MSC’s complimentary cocktail parties invite singles to mix and mingle in a more secluded environment. Also, the amount of onboard entertainment and activities allows countless meeting opportunities for solo travelers.

<p>On eight of its fourteen ships, Costa offers solo cabins, each with a twin bed and some choices between an interior or ocean view room. The only Costa Cruises ship with extra perks for solo travelers is the Costa Diadema, which has the most solo cabins available. </p>

Costa Cruises

On eight of its fourteen ships, Costa offers solo cabins, each with a twin bed and some choices between an interior or ocean view room. The only Costa Cruises ship with extra perks for solo travelers is the Costa Diadema, which has the most solo cabins available.

<p>If you happen to be searching for a cruise within Europe or Asia as a solo traveler, then Amawaterwayes is the ship for you. There are single rooms on four of their river cruise ships, and their boats are already smaller, perfect for a more innate experience. The small ship size allows solo travelers a friendly and comfortable atmosphere in which to relax and socialize with other travelers in the same boat. </p>

AmaWaterways

If you happen to be searching for a cruise within Europe or Asia as a solo traveler, then Amawaterwayes is the ship for you. There are single rooms on four of their river cruise ships, and their boats are already smaller, perfect for a more innate experience. The small ship size allows solo travelers a friendly and comfortable atmosphere in which to relax and socialize with other travelers in the same boat.

<p>The Viking Cruise Line is ideal for solo travelers exploring European countries via cruising. Although this cruise line offers some particular solo traveler deals at times, many travelers say the cruise isn’t worth it. Most travelers dismiss this cruise line with single cabins costing up to 200% more than the double occupancy rate. So, if you are looking into sailing with Viking Cruises as a solo traveler, search for the special fares they offer. </p>

Viking Cruises

The Viking Cruise Line is ideal for solo travelers exploring European countries via cruising. Although this cruise line offers some particular solo traveler deals at times, many travelers say the cruise isn’t worth it. Most travelers dismiss this cruise line with single cabins costing up to 200% more than the double occupancy rate. So, if you are looking into sailing with Viking Cruises as a solo traveler, search for the special fares they offer.

<p>Silversea Cruise Line is the best choice for solo travelers looking for a more intimate setting to meet other travelers. Here, solo travelers can genuinely thrive. Silversea focuses on smaller ship capacity and fosters a more intimate atmosphere, perfect for sparking conversations and developing connections. This cruise line also goes the extra mile with enrichment programs designed to unite all passengers, whether traveling solo or not.</p>

Silversea Cruises

Silversea Cruise Line is the best choice for solo travelers looking for a more intimate setting to meet other travelers. Here, solo travelers can genuinely thrive. Silversea focuses on smaller ship capacity and fosters a more intimate atmosphere, perfect for sparking conversations and developing connections. This cruise line also goes the extra mile with enrichment programs designed to unite all passengers, whether traveling solo or not.

<p>Azamara cruise line is renowned for its destination immersion, making it a perfect fit for those singles looking to cruise lavishly. Be on the lookout for exclusive deals and rates Azamara offers those seeking to travel solo. Also, Azamara offers up to 125% off stateroom fares for those solo travelers.</p>

Azamara cruise line is renowned for its destination immersion, making it a perfect fit for those singles looking to cruise lavishly. Be on the lookout for exclusive deals and rates Azamara offers those seeking to travel solo. Also, Azamara offers up to 125% off stateroom fares for those solo travelers.

<p>So, ditch the fear of missing out and embrace the freedom of solo travel. Set sail confidently, knowing our curated list has identified the top cruise lines catering to solo travelers.</p> <p><strong>More from Travel Reveal:</strong></p> <ul>   <li><a href="https://travelreveal.com/adventure/cruises-from-norfolk-va/">Explore Cruises from Norfolk VA: Your Ticket to Adventure</a></li>   <li><a href="https://travelreveal.com/destination-guides/top-cruise-lines-for-food-lovers/">Top 13 Cruise Lines for Food Lovers</a></li>   <li><a href="https://travelreveal.com/news/11-cruise-ship-features-that-are-phasing-out/">11 Cruise Ship Features That Are Phasing Out</a></li>  </ul> <p>The post <a href="https://travelreveal.com/adventure/15-cruise-lines-for-solo-travelers/">15 Cruise Lines Perfect for Solo Travelers</a> appeared first on <a href="https://travelreveal.com">Travel Reveal</a>.</p>

Bottom Line

So, ditch the fear of missing out and embrace the freedom of solo travel. Set sail confidently, knowing our curated list has identified the top cruise lines catering to solo travelers.

More from Travel Reveal:

  • Explore Cruises from Norfolk VA: Your Ticket to Adventure
  • Top 13 Cruise Lines for Food Lovers
  • 11 Cruise Ship Features That Are Phasing Out

The post 15 Cruise Lines Perfect for Solo Travelers appeared first on Travel Reveal .

More for You

Clint Eastwood and daughter Morgan Eastwood seen at Warner Bros. Pictures 'The 15:17 to Paris' World Premiere, Los Angeles, CA, USA - 5 February 2018

Clint Eastwood, 94, and 8 children reunite in photos for daughter Morgan's wedding at 22-acre ranch

5 common traits of Americans who can never retire

Here are 5 common traits of Americans who can never, ever retire — how many do you have?

Woman discovers allergy

Moment Woman Realizes She Was 'Accidentally Poisoning' Herself for Months

disney-world

Disney World fixes its biggest problem and gives visitors a gift

20240628-teddy_roosevelt-watch-SPLIT.jpg

A Florida auctioneer was about to sell an 1800s pocket watch. He learned it was a stolen piece of US presidential history

There are major changes coming for your washers and dryers

The major changes coming for your washers and dryers in the next three years

Caitlin Clark Rails Against Indiana Fever Coach Christie Sides

Caitlin Clark Rails Against Indiana Fever Coach Christie Sides

Robert Kiyosaki: I used debt to buy 15,000 houses

'I own 15,000 houses': Robert Kiyosaki says there's 'nothing wrong' with buying a house — except he uses debt to buy it and 'pay no taxes'

This type of supplement may increase heart disease risk, new study finds

This type of supplement may increase heart disease risk, new study finds

A mummy found in one of the Egyptian tombs /

Scientists discover hidden 'City of the Dead' with more than 300 tombs

EV driver shares photo of concerning scene at local charging station: 'This angers me so much'

EV driver shares photo of concerning scene at local charging station: 'This angers me so much'

Gov. Gretchen Whitmer delivers remarks

Gretchen Whitmer's Chances of Beating Donald Trump: Poll

Samsung's free 65-inch 4K TV is our favorite deal of 2024 so far

Can't hear TV dialogue? I changed these 3 things to dramatically improve audio

‘I gave up a job that I loved passionately’: My husband secretly set up a trust that includes our home and his investments. What should I do?

‘I gave up a job that I loved passionately’: My husband secretly set up a trust that includes our home and his investments. What should I do?

https://image.cnbcfm.com/api/v1/image/107414133-Unlocked-_Houseboat-_Toronto-_For_Carbon.jpg?v=1715619609&w=1910&h=1000

I live in a $250,000 houseboat in Toronto, Canada: Take a look inside

Bank Account Fees

I’m a Banking Expert: Here’s How Much Money You Should Put in a CD

‘Old People Smell’ Is Real, Here’s What Causes It and How To Avoid It

‘Old People Smell’ Is Real, Here’s What Causes It and How To Avoid It

Frustrated Home Depot employee shares photo of countless carts full of gardening products wasted for no good reason: 'Not our call'

Frustrated Home Depot employee shares photo of countless carts full of gardening products wasted for no good reason: 'Not our call'

A retired boomer who moved from the US to Costa Rica said it's 'horribly incorrect' to assume life in Central America is much cheaper

A retired boomer who moved from the US to Costa Rica said it's 'horribly incorrect' to assume life in Central America is much cheaper

60 Years Ago, the Most Influential Sci-Fi Show Aired its Subversive Final Episode

60 Years Ago, the Most Influential Sci-Fi Show Aired its Subversive Final Episode

This popular cruise line is raising gratuity prices this month

msc cruise vs celebrity

Celebrity Cruises guests may pay a steeper bill next time they sail.

The cruise line is raising its automatic gratuity rates later this month. Charges for standard staterooms will increase from $17.50 to $18 per passenger, per day, while those in Concierge Class and AquaClass staterooms will pay $18.50 per guest each day, up from $18.

Guests in The Retreat suites will pay $23 per passenger, per day, an increase from $21. The changes will take effect July 11.

“The change is in keeping with industry standards and directly recognizes both the exceptional work by our crew to deliver unforgettable vacations every day and the friendly, yet, tailored relaxed luxury experience that Celebrity is known for,” a Celebrity spokesperson said in an emailed statement.

Planning a cruise?: Here are the documents and costs to keep in mind

The cruise line automatically adds gratuities to passengers’ onboard accounts, unless they have an Excluded Booking that include stateroom and restaurant service gratuities and a 20% beverage package tip, according to the line’s website . That applies to Celebrity’s All Included rate, as well as AquaClass staterooms and The Retreat suites.

The changes come as other cruise lines have raised prices in the wake of inflation and the industry's continued recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic . Many have increased gratuity prices , and lines such as MSC Cruises and Carnival Cruise Line have also increased fees for beverage packages .

Nathan Diller is a consumer travel reporter for USA TODAY based in Nashville. You can reach him at [email protected].

  • Celebrity Cruises

MSC YC vs Celebrity Retreat: A comparison

Kteacher

By Kteacher , June 28, 2023 in Celebrity Cruises

Recommended Posts

1,000+ Club

We just returned from our first time on MSC, sailing in YC on the Meraviglia. This will be a comparison between the two experiences. We’ve sailed Retreat on Summit, Reflection, Equinox, and Edge in CS or RS.   

Pre-cruise planning and communication 

  There was no communication from YC prior to boarding. The MSC app was not the most user friendly, and it took several tries before I was able to attach a cc to our onboard account. Celebrity wins here as there has always been shoreside contact pre-cruise with questions about preferences and any specific requests, including specialty dining (more on that later)

Embarkation

We sailed out of Brooklyn, and I don’t think MSC has worked out all the kinks yet. YC guests are brought to a separate line for security, but this line crossed with wheelchair assist, so we were trying to let passengers in wheelchairs go in front of us, and MSC butler was waving to us to just push through. I’m not sure why it was set up so that the lines would cross, but it was chaotic. Once through security we were brought to a smaller room, checked in, then brought on board in small groups by a different butler. We boarded and were then herded to a spot near an elevator and told to wait while the butler took care of something for another guest. Again, chaotic because we were told to wait right where other passengers were boarding the ship. We were then brought up to the YC lounge and told to wait here until our cabin was ready. There was a long line forming behind one desk, and I soon found out this was to book any specialty dining, excursions, or shows. It took about 45 minutes waiting in line to book three specialty restaurants and two shows. Celebrity wins here, no question.

Retreat Lounge vs YC Lounge

The YC lounge was huge! It was also open almost around the clock, with a large bar area, different snacks put out through out the day and into the evening, multiple bar servers, and live music every evening. The YC concierge desk is near the lounge, and seemed to be staffed continually. MSC wins here. We really enjoyed the live music, the bar servers, snacks, the YC Director always around asking if anyone needed anything, and the size of the lounge.

Luminae vs MSC YC Restaurant (and YC buffet!)

Luminae can get a little hectic at times, depending on when you choose to eat. The YC restaurant is very large, so plenty of space for everyone. Food is subjective of course, but we thought the food in YC was really good to excellent. Staff were always around asking checking in to see if we needed anything. What we really liked was just upstairs was a full buffet for YC, open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. There were lots of options as well as a grill for individually prepared items. So food quality is a tie between the two, but slight edge to MSC for having the buffet option.

We were in a Deluxe Balcony Suite, deck 16, right next to the lounge (there is even a secret door to the lounge next to the cabin!). The cabin is smaller, closer in size to a jr suite on Royal Caribbean. The bathroom is also on the small side, and there is about a three inch step up to enter the bathroom. There’s a small closet for hanging items and a small closet with shelves. There were no outlets by the bed, so luckily we had brought an extension cord for my husband’s cpap. The balcony was also on the small side, just large enough for two chairs with foot rests. The mini bar is stocked with water, sodas, juices, and Heineken (the only beer that was available). All YC cabins also get one bottle of spirits (we chose Absolut, and just brought it home with us as drinks were readily available in the lounge). Celebrity wins on cabin size and layout, MSC did a better job on butler service. It was outstanding- we were literally escorted everywhere on the ship we needed to go. The cabins were being serviced all day by the asst. butlers. Everything was always clean, everywhere.

Other observations 

Entertainment on MSC was different than what we are used to. There were included shows that you still needed a reservation for in the main theater and two different paid shows in the Carousel Lounge (12.00 if purchased ahead of time, 18.00 if purchased on the ship and includes one pre-made cocktail. No other drinks served, and the included cocktails were not great). The two paid shows were good, but I’m not sure I would pay for them if I were to cruise again on MSC. There was a Master Chef at Sea competition the last day, and we really enjoyed this.

 We pre-paid for a specialty dining package, three restaurants for 71.00 pp. The packages have a separate menu selection, which was fine. We ended up dining in Butcher’s Cut (steak house), Ocean Cay (seafood), and Kaito Teppanyaki for lunch on the three sea days. We felt the food was better in the YC restaurant than the specialty restaurants, so would not book them again on MSC. Celebrity wins here- we really like their specialty dining as well as dining events like Veuve Cliquot dinner and Daniel Boulud Chef’s Table.

Final Thoughts (and would we book another MSC cruise)

This was a great cruise. We loved the YC experience, and loved MSC’s private island (not going to get into private island debate right now…). The pricing for this cruise in a YC suite was about half what we have been paying for CS on Celebrity, so MSC definitely has the advantage on value for $$$. Would we book MSC again? Yes, if the pricing on MSC stays as competitive as it is now. We’d like to try some different itineraries, so I’ve started checking MSC for interesting looking sailings. Right now we have two Celebrity cruises booked for 2024, one in Aqua because the Retreat pricing was a little crazy. Hope this comparison helps anyone considering an MSC cruise.

Like

Link to comment

Share on other sites.

3,000+ Club

On our trial cruise with MSC we had a smoother pre-cruise and embarkation experience than you did, as there was an email asking for our choice of spirits and our newspaper preference. 

On the newspaper, I wouldn't ask for it another time as I was expecting the sort of small summary sheet that I've had on Regent in the past , but what we got was the whole thing, printed on A3 paper and about half an inch thick... far too much waste for comfort.

Agree on the speciality restaurants, the price is very low compared to Celebrity, you were getting all 3 for around the price of one on Celebrity, but there is no need as the food in the MDR exceeds the specialities, in particular the fillet that is available every day was cooked to perfection and was probably one of the best steaks I've ever had, anywhere...

I'd give Celebrity the edge on the entertainment, especially in Europe as the MSC productions try to appeal to a wide range of different languages, where Celebrity just target English in all markets, so they are more performance focused. ... but Celebrity could use a bit more variety in the production shows.

Yes, we have booked with MSC again, can't argue with better than retreat service levels for Aqua prices...

Lena11033

I did MSC in April I don't know if embarkation organization depends on where, for Southampton it was super easy. I turned up, they took my bags and they walked me through the scanners which took less than a minute, I think I went upstairs after and they finished my boarding process while I had a drink.

Other than the paid theatre I never did a reservation - I just turned up and went into the reserved area for YC.

I will say with the food I had out of Southampton, I would stick away from French/British food - the Italian food was the best I found. The lobster I had on MSC was better than Celebrity.

There were good and bad things for both but the price and what I got on MSC was great - I did do an onboard booking for 2025 for World America.

20,000+ Club

We book celebrity a lot , always suites from sky to penthouse, did MSc yacht club just before Covid shutdown everything, we had no chaos boarding at all . I would say yacht club cabins are similar to sky suites. Loved the entertainment in yacht club lounge which could be heard from restaurant one floor above. Butler was far superior on yacht club he would escort you to shows and off the ship . Captain spent a lot of time there and had a couple pleasant conversations with him . Private island suite area again was far superior to celebrity they had waiter service to bring your food and drink , I thought rest of entertainment was equal to celebrity and there outside area which served lunch was excellent, pool was about 6 ft deep never crowded . I will be definitely look forward to booking them again. They also gave me a ten percent discount on cruise since I am a veteran, never got anything like that from celebrity.

5,000+ Club

I have 4 upcoming MSC YC sailings booked.  2 on Divinia (b2b), 1 on Seascape and 1 on Meraviglia.  I loved the status match (am Diamond on there) and ease of doing so.  2 I chose inside cabin.  The other 2 in December/January were 1/2 the price of the Retreat on the Beyond at the same time which I moved to the Reflection Retreat.  I'm actually debating just cancelling that if I like MSC.  The other thing I liked was the low deposit, the discount for my status, the ability to move my sailing 1x in YC without penalty.  

15 minutes ago, George C said: They also gave me a ten percent discount on cruise since I am a veteran, never got anything like that from celebrity.

I'd forgotten about the cruise price discounts...

They status match from most hotel/airline/cruise loyalty programmes and you can get 5% + an additional 5% if you book more than 6 months in advance. If you are 9 months in advance you get an extra $50 OBC as well.

Also double status points + $200 OBC if you book onboard.

We had considered MSC YC for September with our daughters but now doing a land trip.  

Can I ask please what the rest of the ship is like once you leave YC? X is imo good everywhere most of the time.   

Forgot to add that we like the non smoking inside & that’s a big deal for us.

3 hours ago, wineoclock said: Can I ask please what the rest of the ship is like once you leave YC? X is imo good everywhere most of the time. 

We were on Divina, cruising near Italy, so we walked through the ship each day to get to the Yacht Club restaurant.

We only found it noticeably busy on the gala night, but there were so many bars, with different entertainment in each, that even then the people tended to spread out between them (all serve coffee as well).

Didn't see an issue with finding seats or a table had we chosen to stay in any of them. General atmosphere was more 'lively' and culturally diverse than X. 

We never noticed any cigarette smoke even in the casino, and the one inside smokers lounge always looked empty as we went past, so I'm guessing we didn't have many smokers onboard, so every cruise is going to be different.

I guess the big difference we noticed was the general ambiance, X can feel a little sterile at times, where MSC always felty like people were having fun, but there was both quiet and party spaces available just a walk away, never felt like we would have to hunt down a bar with space to sit as we have had to do on Silhouette or Eclipse at times.

The atmosphere in the Yacht Club itself felt way better than the Retreat as there was some form of, appropriate, live music in the lounge every evening. The butlers also work in the lounge, so there is rarely a wait for table service.

Can't comment on what it was like around the main pools on a sea day so it could well have been a bit more of a 'zoo' down there, but again quite a few different spaces including an 'adults only' are for those not wishing to deal with excitable children 🙂

If we had to sail outside the Yacht Club for a great itinerary I think we probably would still do it, but at current prices we would always be more inclined to book Yacht Club.

Thank you so much! We are in  CS on Apex next but definitely I’m beginning to look elsewhere at those retreat prices 😁

Stem to Stern

Stem to Stern

20 hours ago, Kteacher said: This was a great cruise. We loved the YC experience, and loved MSC’s private island (not going to get into private island debate right now…). The pricing for this cruise in a YC suite was about half what we have been paying for CS on Celebrity, so MSC definitely has the advantage on value for $$$. Would we book MSC again? Yes, if the pricing on MSC stays as competitive as it is now

Your entire review and most of the commentary that followed resonates with me.  Prior to this I was encouraged by Charla's live from MSC thread.  We status matched to Diamond, so were able to take advantage of MSC's incentives for our first booking foray into the Yacht Club.  We will be doing a side-by-side comparison of MSC Yacht Club with The Retreat on board Summit.  We have previously enjoyed The Retreat on board Silhouette and Equinox, but we look forward to trying it on board a Revolutionized M-class ship.  I am not looking to uncover any miraculous discoveries during the comparison, but it will be interesting to disembark one ship and nearly immediately embark the other.  The 5-night on the Summit was booked first.  Then, we tacked on the 7-nights on Seascape after I got Charlacized by her review.  We will be sailing glass-half-full after suffering a lonnng, land-locked 363-day cruise hiatus.  We are always grateful and happy just to have booked cruises to look forward to.  Any day on any ship (within $$$ reason) beats a day on land.

RichYak

25 minutes ago, Stem to Stern said: after I got Charlacized by her review

Excellent choice of words! And now I'm off to read and learn about Franz Mesmer.

Haha

4 minutes ago, RichYak said: Excellent choice of words! And now I'm off to read and learn about Franz Mesmer.

I get ized easily I guess.  Maybe on my next cruise I will get YCized like the time I was Crystalized on board Serenity.

22 hours ago, Kteacher said: We just returned from our first time on MSC, sailing in YC on the Meraviglia. This will be a comparison between the two experiences.

You didn't touch on the outdoor YC space vs Retreat sundeck at all. Seems to me to be a huge win for MSC vs. all but E-class ships.

miched

I recently booked a cruise in the Yacht Club.    

The price of the cruise went down because of a 4th of July sale.   I called about getting the price match and was told that MSC doesn’t do a price match.    I was told that the deposits for the Yacht Club are NR so I could cancel the cruise and rebook but the loss of the deposit would offset most of the decrease.    

Just something to think about when booking a MSC cruise.     

For the most part  the MSC appears to be a better value and offers fantastic service according to the reviews I have read.    I haven’t traveled with them yet so I can only go by those reports.  

It also appears as if they nickel dime for many things that you would expect to be included.  Still not a deal breaker for the difference in cost.     

Happy cruising 🌊 🚢 🇺🇸 🌅

5 hours ago, RichYak said: You didn't touch on the outdoor YC space vs Retreat sundeck at all. Seems to me to be a huge win for MSC vs. all but E-class ships.

Sorry about that.Yes, the YC sun deck (which includes the buffet area) is very spacious with plenty of loungers, towels and bar servers coming around with water, drinks, basically whatever you wanted they brought to you. The only negative I could find is there isn’t much shade.

cublet

On 6/28/2023 at 10:02 PM, Mark_T said: I'd forgotten about the cruise price discounts...   They status match from most hotel/airline/cruise loyalty programmes and you can get 5% + an additional 5% if you book more than 6 months in advance. If you are 9 months in advance you get an extra $50 OBC as well.   Also double status points + $200 OBC if you book onboard.

This is either the pedant in me or the retired accountant in me but a word of clarification on the cruise discounts. You get an extra 5% off the 95% so 9.75% in total and not 10%.

I am pleased to say that the OBCs are given as shown above to solo travellers and not pro-rated.

3 hours ago, cublet said: This is either the pedant in me or the retired accountant in me but a word of clarification on the cruise discounts. You get an extra 5% off the 95% so 9.75% in total and not 10%.

It is 5% discount from 100%, then 5% of the 95%, which is why I expressed it as they do, which is 5 + 5 rather than 10, so it was a good point to mkae 🙂

3 hours ago, cublet said: I am pleased to say that the OBCs are given as shown above to solo travellers and not pro-rated.  

Not all OBC is applied that way though, the promotion that was on when we made our booking is specifically for double occupancy cabins, so a solo traveller would have received half...

Screenshot2023-06-09at13-49-24OnBoardCreditPromoMSCCruises.thumb.png.296b86f0b70c17975c53f636faca3705.png

On 6/29/2023 at 1:04 PM, Stem to Stern said: Your entire review and most of the commentary that followed resonates with me.  Prior to this I was encouraged by Charla's live from MSC thread.  We status matched to Diamond, so were able to take advantage of MSC's incentives for our first booking foray into the Yacht Club.  We will be doing a side-by-side comparison of MSC Yacht Club with The Retreat on board Summit.  We have previously enjoyed The Retreat on board Silhouette and Equinox, but we look forward to trying it on board a Revolutionized M-class ship.  I am not looking to uncover any miraculous discoveries during the comparison, but it will be interesting to disembark one ship and nearly immediately embark the other.  The 5-night on the Summit was booked first.  Then, we tacked on the 7-nights on Seascape after I got Charlacized by her review.  We will be sailing glass-half-full after suffering a lonnng, land-locked 363-day cruise hiatus.  We are always grateful and happy just to have booked cruises to look forward to.  Any day on any ship (within $$$ reason) beats a day on land.

Where can I find Charla’s commentary on MSC? Love her writing! TYIA

perakcruiser

On 6/30/2023 at 7:13 AM, miched said: It also appears as if they nickel dime for many things that you would expect to be included.  Still not a deal breaker for the difference in cost.   

That is not true at all. There is only one thing, you have to pay for the water in the MDR, which is free on most other cruise lines. Not in YC of cause, there is a premium drinks package included.

And their price structure of cause makes it impossible for them to do a price match. 

57 minutes ago, perakcruiser said: That is not true at all. There is only one thing, you have to pay for the water in the MDR, which is free on most other cruise lines. Not in YC of cause, there is a premium drinks package included.   And their price structure of cause makes it impossible for them to do a price match. 

I am not complaining about the price match.   I am only posting to let others know and think about when booking if you think that a “sale” may be coming.     When I booked I didn’t ask about being price match as I am use to sailing on Celebrity and other cruise lines that did a price match. 

if you read the reviews of MSC you will read a lot of things that people complain about having to pay extra for, some are and some are not in the Yacht Club.    As I wrote I can only go by what they wrote as I haven’t been on MSC 

I booked the Yacht Club and it is only for 3 nights.  If there is a charge for something and I want it I will pay for it.   I booked the cruise because it is only 3 nights so I could get a feel for the cruise line.  It is 5 days before a B2B Celebrity cruise and  on the way driving from MI to FL.  If I don’t like it fine,  if it is fantastic then I will book more. 

On an X site I am surprised there isn't more enthusiasm for the Retreat. We loved YC but booked a

discounted Sky Suite on Ascent for next year. With credits it was approx the same price as YC which has gone up alot like everything. We saw some potential YC benefits (never having sailed on Retreat).

These include the spa access, stocked mini bar, and private island which is not part of our X cruise.

We were thinking of migrating to YC for this Jan 2024 cruise but discovered that YC now has non refundable deposit. Anyway we will probably stick with the new Ascent and see how we like it. I would have to be very impressed to spend 7-10 grand a week for Carib cruise in Retreat. Sorry to be such a downer but as long time cruisers we just don't have the same enthusiasm we used to for cruising primarily because of the declining (IMHO) value. 

8 hours ago, JackE said: Where can I find Charla’s commentary on MSC? Love her writing! TYIA

She did a back-to-back on Celebrity and MSC.  Enjoy! 🙂

Yes YC has a non refundable deposit but when I booked in April for 2025 the deposit was $200 not a percentage of the total cost.

OK...after about 30 cruises, tried MSC in Feb (NOT YC)

Wasn't a fan--tried again in May. Even less of a fan now.

We did Retreat on Beyond in April. Really enjoyed it but would have to get a similar deal as we got on that one to do it again--nothing was so much better to pay a huge premium for.

Would I try MSC again if we did YC? 

Maybe, if the price was right.

But I found the passengers to be rude on both sailings (one in Caribbean & one in Europe...)--which is an issue that many reviewers point out.

And the activities & entertainment were, well, odd.

I agree with above poster about Celebrity shows--EXCEPT Eclass. Those are on another level.

45 minutes ago, KKB said: But I found the passengers to be rude on both sailings (one in Caribbean & one in Europe...)--which is an issue that many reviewers point out.

Tami, who often posts on the Celebrity board, is currently on board MSC in YC and went out of her way to indicate that she is having the opposite experience.

Screenshot 2023-07-01 210650.jpg

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in

  • Welcome to Cruise Critic
  • ANNOUNCEMENT: Set Sail on Sun Princess®
  • Hurricane Zone 2024
  • Cruise Insurance Q&A w/ Steve Dasseos of Tripinsurancestore.com June 2024
  • New Cruisers
  • Cruise Lines “A – O”
  • Cruise Lines “P – Z”
  • River Cruising
  • Cruise Critic News & Features
  • Digital Photography & Cruise Technology
  • Special Interest Cruising
  • Cruise Discussion Topics
  • UK Cruising
  • Australia & New Zealand Cruisers
  • Canadian Cruisers
  • North American Homeports
  • Ports of Call
  • Cruise Conversations

Announcements

  • New to Cruise Critic? Join our Community!

Write Your Own Amazing Review !

WAR_icy_SUPERstar777.jpg

Click this gorgeous photo by member SUPERstar777 to share your review!

Features & News

LauraS

LauraS · Started Thursday at 08:52 PM

LauraS · Started Thursday at 07:30 PM

LauraS · Started Tuesday at 05:03 PM

LauraS · Started Tuesday at 03:34 PM

LauraS · Started Tuesday at 03:22 PM

hal5starpcbest2024.jpg

  • Existing user? Sign in OR Create an Account
  • Find Your Roll Call
  • Meet & Mingle
  • Community Help Center
  • All Activity
  • Member Photo Albums
  • Meet & Mingle Photos
  • Favorite Cruise Memories
  • Cruise Food Photos
  • Cruise Ship Photos
  • Ports of Call Photos
  • Towel Animal Photos
  • Amazing, Funny & Totally Awesome Cruise Photos
  • Write a Review
  • Live Cruise Reports
  • Member Cruise Reviews
  • Create New...

msc cruise vs celebrity

COMMENTS

  1. Celebrity Cruises vs MSC Cruises for June 2024

    MSC Cruises is an Italian-themed, family-oriented cruise line with a fleet of 23 ships that sail to destinations worldwide. They offer a wide range of itineraries, from short Caribbean cruises to longer world cruises. Caribbean sailings are one of their specialties, with budget-friendly fares often starting at $139 per person for a three-night ...

  2. Overall Comparison between MSC and Celebrity!

    Posted October 24, 2021. MSC is a mass-market line, while Celebrity tends to serve a premium market. It's not a good comparison. One is a low-cost Walmart, while the other is sort of a Whole Foods. The only comparable aspect between the two is their concierge experience, which is truly cost effective on MSC.

  3. Celebrity vs. MSC

    But MSC is certainly several cuts above Carnival and similar. Food quality is better on Celebrity. Celebrity has better drinks in their drink package. Also, if you buy a more expensive drink on Celebrity than what is allowed by your drink package, you pay the difference. On MSC, you pay the full price of the drink.

  4. MSC vs Celebrity...

    MSC ships are definitely more glitzy, Celebrity more subdued. My experience is there is more of a party atmosphere on MSC, especially on the short 3/4 day cruises. But on longer cruises with a larger percentage of guests from outside North America, they are more refined. I can't tell where you are from, but since you sailed Euribia, I thought ...

  5. CELEBRITY vs MSC CRUISES review : Are they High End Cruise Lines?

    Overall Value. When it comes to value, both CELEBRITY and MSC CRUISES offer an experience like no other. The memories and moments created during your time on board are priceless. While the initial cost may seem high, the value in terms of quality, service, and unforgettable experiences far exceeds the price tag.

  6. MSC Seashore vs Celebrity Beyond

    Cruise Costs. MSC is considered a mainstream cruise line. Mainstream cruise lines cater to a variety of guests, hoping to provide something for everyone. These typically cost about $100 - $350 per person per day. Celebrity, on the other hand, is a premium cruise line. Premium cruise lines typically offer upscale food, accommodations, and service.

  7. Cruise ship guide: 20 popular lines explained

    Cunard. A storied line with roots that go back to the 1800s, this three-ship brand is perhaps best known for its 2,695-passenger flagship, Queen Mary 2. The ship lives up to its billing as a true ocean liner with semiregular, transatlantic service between Southampton, England, and New York.

  8. MSC vs Celebrity...

    MSC tops Celebrity with their Yacht Club over Celebrity's Retreat, in the "ship within a ship" suite concept at one half Celebrity prices. Theatre productions and over all entertainment, like the food, I found the same, except Celebrity has Cafe al Bacio with 12-14 complimentary pastries all day and night.

  9. Msc vs. Celebrity

    Posted March 19, 2012. So, our 4th cruise has come and gone and thought to share my experience and comparisons to MSC. We tried Celebrity Constellation on a 14 night southern Caribbean itinerary. Ship. MSC-Beautiful, tasteful décor, modern and open spaces, pool a little crowded. Celebrity-Recently refurbished, and Solciticized.

  10. MSC vs Celebrity

    461. September 3, 2007. INDIANA. #1. Posted December 27, 2018. We currently have an August 2020 cruise on the Apex booked with Celebrity in an Aft cabin. It sails to Spain, France and Italy. I started researching MSC and the Yacht Club- a similar itinerary on MSC in Yacht club is $1500 less for a Delusd suite (or whatever the lowest level is in ...

  11. MSC vs Celebrity?

    We are avid cruisers who love Celebrity S class ships. I have recently been reading where Celebrity cruisers are moving to MSC. What do you love about MSC?

  12. MSC vs Celebrity?

    Our first cruise on MSC was a 14 Caribbean cruise on the Seaside, we were hooked. We have the same cruise booked agin this October. We can't compare it to a Celebrity suite as they are just too expensive. On both cruises, we paid less than $200 p.p. per day. This included all taxes, fees, gratuities, and drink package.

  13. Differences Between Major Cruise Lines

    Norwegian Cruise Line offers the ultimate in flexibility at sea with its freestyle cruising approach, giving passengers more freedom to choose among different dining options, activities, and ...

  14. MSC vs Celebrity? : r/Cruise

    Celebrity is a premium line with certain qualities (including pax : crew and pax : space ratios) commensurate with that part of the market. MSC is a contemporary line. Expect much larger crowds, less attention to detail, etc. In short, it depends what you prefer and value. There are a ton of lines out there.

  15. We Tested 9 BRAND NEW Cruise Ships

    These vessels include Holland America Line's Rotterdam, Royal Caribbean's Wonder of the Seas, Princess Cruises' Discovery Princess, Disney Wish, Norwegian Prima, Virgin Voyages' Valiant Lady, Celebrity Beyond, Carnival Celebration, and MSC Seascape. WE COMPARED 9 BRAND NEW SHIPS IN OUR LATEST VIDEO!

  16. MSC Yacht Club vs Celebrity (not Retreat) : r/Cruise

    Previously, our favorite line was Celebrity, but for family cruising, we're planning on more MSC cruises. The atmosphere was very similar and Yacht Club would give the luxury. The Divina's decor was gorgeous! We prefer more elegant/less cartoonish decor, like on Celebrity, We didn't even have YC and still found the cruise more luxurious than ...

  17. Comparison of Celebrity Vs MSC

    The number and variety of live music on MSC is much higher. I have been on Celebrity cruises were the last live music finished at 11, and shortly after everything was dead. On MSC you can expect many styles of music until late. Celebrity has terrible electronic instruments instead of real strings, in MSC you might even get an Opera performance.

  18. MSC vs Celebrity?

    MSC Cruises ; MSC vs Celebrity? MSC vs Celebrity? By artistcleveland, January 11, 2011 in MSC Cruises. Share More sharing options... Followers 1. Prev; 1; 2; Next; Page 1 of 2 . Recommended Posts. artistcleveland. Posted January 11, 2011. artistcleveland. Members; 165 June 17, 2010; Ohio

  19. Celebrity Retreat vs MSC Yacht Club

    We have celebrity retreat several times including very recently on Beyond and also Edge , in general I give a edge to MSc yacht club, love the truly ship within a ship , on yacht club all your cabins , restaurants and bars are in this area you can't enter without being in a yacht club cabin, the inside suite lounge is beautiful and much larger and nicer than celebrity with a baby grand piano ...

  20. 15 Cruise Lines Perfect for Solo Travelers

    Celebrity Apex is the #1 ship for singles looking to mingle. There are several options for solo travelers to mingle, such as social events and solo excursions. ... MSC Cruises. MSC has multiple ...

  21. The 7 Most Affordable Cruise Lines of 2023, Ranked

    Carnival Cruise Line—known as one of the most affordable cruise lines—was founded in 1972 and now carries millions of guests every year aboard its 24 ships.It sails to Alaska, the Bahamas ...

  22. MSC Yacht Club vs. Celebrity Retreat

    Posted August 11, 2022. This was from this past April. We just got off Celebrity Silhouette where we spent a glorious 11 nights in a Sky Suite in Celebrity's Retreat which is like MSC's Yacht Club. Thought I'd share a few thoughts on retreat vs's yacht club. Let me clarify we have done Yacht club 6 times.

  23. River Cruise vs. Ocean Cruise: What's the Difference?

    1. Destinations Hold The Spotlight on River Cruises. The largest mainstream ocean cruise lines, Carnival Cruise Line, Royal Caribbean, Norwegian Cruise Line, and MSC Cruises, go to great lengths ...

  24. Celebrity VS MSC?

    The reviews for Med cruises regularly include complaints about loud and pushy passengers that don't know how to wait their turn. This reviews on this site has Celebrity-81% Loved it, MSC-53% Loved It. That's nearly a third more passengers loving Celebrity. Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk.

  25. Celebrity Cruises will hike gratuity rates this month

    Celebrity Cruises guests may pay a steeper bill next time they sail. The cruise line is raising its automatic gratuity rates later this month. Charges for standard staterooms will increase from ...

  26. CELEBRITY BEYOND vs MSC SEASHORE

    Like to cruise a bit as time is running out and chose the Celebrity Beyond Retreat since our present favorite cruise ship, the Seashore, is no longer sailing from a South Florida port this month and the Seascape is coming to South Florida next month. We booked a Royal Suite (560/70 sq ft) to compare it to the Royal Suite on Seashore Yacht Club ...

  27. MSC YC vs Celebrity Retreat: A comparison

    Yes, if the pricing on MSC stays as competitive as it is now. We'd like to try some different itineraries, so I've started checking MSC for interesting looking sailings. Right now we have two Celebrity cruises booked for 2024, one in Aqua because the Retreat pricing was a little crazy. Hope this comparison helps anyone considering an MSC ...